THE YEOMEN OF THE
GUARD, Buxton Opera House
It’s good that the
Gilbert & Sullivan festival, though now removed from Buxton to Harrogate,
lets its old home in on a bit of the action by sending its National Gilbert
& Sullivan Opera Company there, at least for a few days.
I saw The Yeomen Of
The Guard, my favourite of all the standard G&S operas. What I love about
it is the sense that Sullivan is trying out some ideas for a model of English
vernacular opera – more Romantic than most of his other collaborations with
Gilbert – seeking the Holy Grail of a popular lyric style based on ‘traditional’
English music, as identified by Macfarren and others, but bringing in some of
the qualities of his own time. At times it sounds almost like Dvorak. He took it
a stage further with Ivanhoe, shortly afterwards (the opening production at
what we now know as the Palace Theatre on Shaftesbury Avenue, then the new English
Opera House), but alas found no real successor.
It’s also got a superb
book in which Gilbert produces mock-Tudor dialogue that is still perfectly
comprehensible, and a storyline with pathos – tragedy, even – mixed with comedy
on an almost Shakespearean level. It’s a long way from the topsy-turvydom of
much of the rest of popular G&S.
The result is a very
fine series of second act numbers, and slightly grander operatic features in
the overture and two act finales, than you get elsewhere. Director John
Savournin responds to these with imagination, darkening the stage and stilling
the silliness from time to time, and ending the opera with a curtain-call
line-up minus bows or curtseys. The tears – and death – of a clown (in this
case, the jester Jack Point, who finally loses his longed-for love, Elsie
Maynard) are moving indeed when you’re forced to look them in the face.
Richard Gauntlett is a
class act as Jack Point, though not quite the master of the patter song that
some of his predecessors have been, but superb in the final scene. Jane
Harrington, too, has a fine voice and presence as Elsie. Bruce Graham, a
seasoned veteran of the G&S tradition, brings his clarity and stage sense
to Shadbolt the jailer (who eventually gets his prize in Phoebe, beautifully acted
and sung by Fiona Mackay). And the noble English tenor role of Fairfax is very
well taken by Nicholas Sales, fitting it like a glove in Free From His Fetters
Grim and elsewhere.
One thing Yeomen needs
is a generous collection of principal talent, as there are two quartets with
only the tenor role in common (Strange Adventure – beautifully sung with English Vocal Union seriousness – and When A
Wooer Goes A-Wooing) . Here they had the resources for it, and conductor David
Steadman paced and phrased the score with a sure hand.